An administrative hearing in Tallahassee on Tuesday could determine the fate of Broward County Sheriff Gregory Tony’s police certification.
The Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE) brought forth a complaint against Tony in 2022, alleging that he made false statements on his Florida driver’s license applications by failing to disclose past license suspensions in Pennsylvania in 1993 and 1998.
Tony’s driver’s license had been suspended five times when he lived in Pennsylvania, Florida Department of Law Enforcement Assistant General Counsel Natalie Bielby told Administrative Law Judge Robert L. Kilbride.
At the heart of the matter is whether Tony’s actions constitute a violation of the state statute requiring law enforcement officers to possess “good moral character.”
The case is being heard by the state Criminal Justice Standards and Training Commission, which has the power to pursue a case if the alleged “misconduct violates state officer standards.”
FDLE vs Sheriff Tony
The FDLE seeks to convince a judge that Tony’s alleged dishonesty warrants disciplinary action, potentially including the revocation of his certification.
Tony’s legal team is expected to have an opportunity to cross-examine a key FDLE inspector later in the proceedings.
Tony’s lawyers argue in court filings that he “did not commit the misconduct alleged and has not violated officer standards.” They also argue the state “cannot prove the alleged felony offenses by clear and convincing evidence.”
If the judge rules in favor of the FDLE’s argument, the Broward Sheriff could lose his authority to make arrests or perform law enforcement duties in Florida, although he would still be permitted to retain his position as sheriff, as elected officials in Florida are not mandated to hold law enforcement certifications.
The potential ramifications extend beyond Tony’s law enforcement powers. Questions arise about whether he would continue to wear a uniform and what political implications may arise, especially given Tony’s reelection bid in 2024 as a Democrat.
Tony’s hearing is scheduled to last two days and there is no jury. The judge will review the evidence.
