Phil Simmons Says Batting at Fault After West Indies Defeat

Head Coach Phil Simmons has defended West Indies’ preparation for the opening Test following their crushing innings defeat inside 2 ½ days in St Lucia on Saturday, but said they now needed to raise their intensity and rebound strongly in the second Test beginning this week.

The home side produced two lacklustre batting efforts, rolled over for 97 in their first innings and then for 162 in their second, to slide to a heavy loss late in an extended first session on yesterday’s third day at the Daren Sammy National Stadium.

While West Indies spent a month prior to the opening Test in a high-performance camp, Simmons said they had been undermined by poor batting.

“Bad judgement, bad shot selection — however you want to put it. You can’t be out for 97 [in the first innings] and there’s any other question [about the result]. It’s just about bad selection in the first innings especially,” Simmons lamented afterwards.

“The fact is we need to bat well in the first innings. We need to bat a hundred overs and we need to find a way to do that against this team.

- Advertisement -

“I think if we bat a hundred overs against this team, we’re putting ourselves in a good position to put them under pressure.”

He added: “All the guys here, from one to nine at least, have Test fifties against proper bowling attacks. Yes, they (South Africa) are potent but the guys have made runs against all different kinds of bowling attacks.

“I think that the way we got out was not something we would be proud of and we have to come back and show what we’re really made of in the second Test.”

West Indies lost a grip on the contest once they were dismissed cheaply after opting to bat and then conceding a massive lead of 225, as South Africa gathered 322 behind Quinton de Kock’s superb unbeaten 141.

They finished day two on 82 for four but lost wickets steadily in the first session yesterday to collapse, despite Roston Chase’s defiant 62.

With the second Test starting Friday, Simmons said it was important that the side again prepared themselves mentally in order to get a positive result.

“I think in each person themselves, they have to get themselves fired up,” a composed Simmons explained.

“We have to put them back through the paces that we did leading up to the Test match and prepare in as diligent a way as we did prepare going into this one and maybe add a little bit more.

“Over the next couple days, we’ll sit and have a look back at the Test match itself. I personally think that the preparation and training we did before was quite intense, but we’ll see if we missed anything and try to put that in.

“But that’s all you can do because you as a Test cricketer have to fix your mindset and make sure your mindset is ready for it, and we’ve done that a lot of times leading up to this and in the past.”

For West Indies, the defeat was their first in five matches this year after thumping Bangladesh 2-0 away and drawing nil-all at home with Sri Lanka in another two-match series.

That form propelled them up to sixth in the ICC Test rankings, one notch above the Proteas, but Simmons said the heavy defeat was now cause for deep introspection.

“It will definitely be [a reality check] for me. I don’t take things for granted,” he stressed.

“I think we played well in four Test matches but again, that’s only the start of how we have to get up the table and how much we have to play, so this has shown us that there is a lot of work still to be done which we kept reiterating to the players all last week.

“There’s a lot of work still to be done so we have to keep working.”

CMC

More Stories

stuart-young-trinidad

Trinidad’s general election date announced: April 28, 2025

Prime Minister Stuart Young has announced that Trinidad and Tobago’s general election will be held on April 28, 2025. The announcement came on Tuesday,...
Usain Bolt

Usain Bolt donates $2 million to William Knibb Memorial ahead of Champs

Jamaican sprint legend Usain Bolt has once again demonstrated his unwavering commitment to his alma mater, William Knibb Memorial High School, with a $2...
US travel ban

US dismisses travel ban reports that include Caribbean nations

The U.S. Department of State has dismissed reports suggesting that a new travel ban could impact multiple countries, including several in the Caribbean. Despite...
Antigua and Barbuda says it will accept nationals deported from the US

Antigua PM faces US scrutiny over Russian megayacht sale

A U.S. federal judge has authorized attorneys representing a Russian woman to access financial records related to the controversial sale of a seized megayacht...
St. Vincent Guyana-Venezuela border

St. Vincent Prime Minister Gonsalves meets Maduro over Guyana-Venezuela border tensions

The government of St. Vincent and the Grenadines has confirmed that Prime Minister Dr. Ralph Gonsalves traveled to Venezuela to meet with President Nicolás...
Haiti

Armed gangs in Haiti attack three news outlets in coordinated assault

Armed gangs launched coordinated attacks on three major media outlets in Haiti's capital over the weekend, escalating concerns over press freedom and the government's...
CONCACAF Gold Cup Jamaica

McClaren puts faith in homegrown talent for CONCACAF Gold Cup showdown

Jamaica’s national football team is set to take the field for the CONCACAF Gold Cup qualifiers with an unprecedented level of local representation in...
Jamaica’s Special Olympic

Jamaica Special Olympics team returns home with unmatched success

Jamaica’s Special Olympics delegation is basking in glory after a record-breaking performance at the 2025 World Winter Games in Turin, Italy. The team captured an...
Michail Antonio reflects on life after life-altering car crash

West Ham’s Michail Antonio vows comeback after devastating car crash

On a stormy December day, Michail Antonio’s world came crashing down—literally. The West Ham and Jamaican international striker lost control of his Ferrari just outside...
Randy Harris’ historic rise to FIFA’s

Barbadian PM Mia Mottley hails Randy Harris’ historic rise to FIFA’s top ranks

Barbados has taken its place on football’s world stage, marking a historic breakthrough with the election of Randy Harris to the prestigious FIFA Council. In...

Latest Articles

Skip to content