Jury tampering highlighted as key issue during Vybz Kartel Privy Council appeal hearing

The Privy Council appeal hearing of Jamaican dancehall star Vybz Kartel and his three co-accused began on Wednesday in London, with the appellants’ lawyers highlighting attempts to bribe the trial jury and the use of incriminating messages as reasons their convictions should not stand.

Kartel, along with his co-defendants, Shawn Campbell (also known as Shawn Storm), Kahira Jones, and Andre St John, have been in jail in Jamaica since 2011. They were found guilty of the 2011 murder of Clive “Lizard” Williams.

Kartel was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2014 with a minimum of 35 years, later reduced on appeal to 32-and-a-half.

The issue in this appeal is whether the men’s convictions are safe in light of the following grounds of challenge:

* Should the trial judge have excluded the telecommunications evidence relied on by the prosecution?

- Advertisement -

* How should the judge have handled the allegations that there were attempts to bribe members of the jury during the trial? Should the jury (or the particular juror said to have offered the bribes) have been discharged?

* Was the judge wrong to invite the jury to reach a verdict late in the day, given the special circumstances of the case?

Arguments from lawyers

On Wednesday, British law lords heard submissions from King’s Counsel Hugh Southey, who is representing Jones and St John, and Isat Buchanan, representing Vybz Kartel.

Southey’s arguments primarily centered around potential breaches of the Charter of Rights in relation to telecommunications evidence, and issues of jury tampering.

During the trial in 2014, the appellants challenged the admissibility of phone evidence, arguing that its acquisition violated the Interception of Communications Act and infringed upon the fundamental right to privacy of communication as guaranteed by the Jamaican Constitution. However, the trial judge deemed the telecommunications evidence admissible.

During the 64-day trial, the judge was also alerted to an allegation that a juror had attempted to bribe others by offering $500,000 JMD for a specific verdict. After investigating the allegation and consulting with counsel for both the prosecution and defense, the judge opted to continue the trial without dismissing the jury or the implicated juror.

Southey pointed out that since the juror, Livingston Caine, was found guilty on a charge of attempting to pervert the course of justice, he could not have been relied on to follow the directives of the judge in the case. He said Caine’s conviction ultimately stains the verdict in the Vybz Kartel case.

He stated that when the issue was brought up during the trial, Caine should have been dismissed. He noted that if Caine had not been allowed to continue, the entire jury would have had to be dismissed and the trial would have to be restarted since one juror had already been discharged.

Southey argued that while the restart of the trial would have been an issue given the fact that the trial had already been lengthy, “If that’s what’s required, that’s what’s required.”

Law lords seemingly agreed that the trial judge should not have side-stepped the provision of discharging a juror where there is sufficient basis to discharge them (i.e. being found guilty of attempting to pervert the course of justice).

But lawyers representing Jamaican prosecutors said the trial judge was right to allow the messages into evidence and in how he dealt with the jury.

“The evidence in the case against all the appellants was overwhelming, in particular in the case of Mr. Palmer,” Peter Knox said in court filings.

He added: “Even if there were irregularities in the trial, they did not result in a serious miscarriage of justice.” He noted that even if there was one juror who was bribed, there were an additional 10 jurors who came in with a guilty verdict.

The appeal hearing continues on February 15. The appeal judges are Lord Reed, Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Briggs, Lord Burrows, and Lady Simler.

Read more: Vybz Kartel Privy Council hearing to be streamed live

More Stories

Oliver Samuels

Oliver Samuels to receive lifetime honor at 42nd IRAWMA Awards

Legendary actor and comedian Dr. Oliver Samuels, OD, will be honored with a 55-year Golden Lifetime Award and named the "Caribbean King of Comedy"...
Dionne Warwick

Dionne Warwick set to enchant Jamaica with a ‘Timeless’ musical experience

On March 29, 2025, music lovers in Jamaica are in for a treat when legendary singer Dionne Warwick headlines a star-studded event at Plantation...
Tasha Cobbs

Miramar Cultural Center to host Gospel Star Tasha Cobbs on April 5

Gospel music fans are in for a night of soul-stirring inspiration as the Miramar Cultural Center presents the acclaimed Tasha Cobbs Leonard on Saturday,...
shaggy and sting

Sting and Shaggy Perform ‘Til A Mawnin’ on The Tonight Show

Reggae icons Sting and Shaggy recently brought their latest single, Til A Mawnin, to live television audiences with performances on LIVE with Kelly and...
spice-army-at-red-bull-culture-clash

Spice Army wins Red Bull Culture Clash 2025

The Queen of Dancehall, Spice, and her powerhouse crew, Spice Army, have claimed victory at the Red Bull Culture Clash 2025 in London, solidifying...
jah cure

Jah Cure to face Netherlands Court of Appeals in June hearing

Reggae artist Jah Cure is set to appear before the Netherlands Court of Appeals on June 18, 2025, for a substantive hearing that will...

Reggae fans and Jamaican officials pay tribute to icon Cocoa Tea

The reggae world is reeling from the loss of legendary Jamaican singer Cocoa Tea, who passed away on Monday at the age of 65...
King Charles praises Bob Marley

King Charles praises Bob Marley’s legacy: ‘He gave the world a voice’

King Charles has paid tribute to reggae legend Bob Marley, describing his “marvellous, infectious energy” and the lasting influence of his music. In a new...
Jahshii and Bugle

Jahshii & Bugle to headline Livewire’s second instalment at Tracks & Records

After a spectacular debut, the Livewire concert series returns to Tracks & Records on Thursday, March 27, with two powerhouse artistes—Jahshii and Bugle—set to...
Cocoa Tea

Reggae legend Cocoa Tea dies at 65 in Fort Lauderdale

Jamaican reggae singer Cocoa Tea, known for his smooth vocals and timeless hits, has died at the age of 65. He passed away on...

Latest Articles

Skip to content