Guyana school fire: Attorney seeks withdrawal of murder charges against student

An attorney for a 15-year-old student accused of causing a fatal fire on May 22 at Mahdia Secondary School’s dormitory in Guyana, which resulted in the death of 19 students, has urged the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) to dismiss the charges. 

The tragic event at the school took the lives of students aged between 12 to 17 and a five-year-old boy.

Legal defense’s argument: Lack of evidence and weak case

Dr. Dexter Todd, the lawyer representing the teenager, conveyed in a correspondence to the DPP that the evidence presented at the Mahdia Magistrate’s Court hearings indicates a lack of substantial proof to validate the murder charges against the young defendant.

Todd emphasized the weaknesses in the case, highlighting the circumstantial nature of the evidence presented. 

Deadly blaze at Mahdia Secondary School.
Deadly blaze at Mahdia Secondary School.
(CMC photo)

More on the fire at Mahdia Secondary School’s dormitory

Prosecution’s claims: Threats and circumstantial evidence

Reports are that the accused had a disagreement with the dormitory’s caretaker over a confiscated cellphone and subsequently made threats to set the dormitory on fire. However, Todd argued that this alleged threat hardly establishes a concrete link to the devastating event.

- Advertisement -

Moreover, Todd underscored the absence of direct evidence tying the teenager to the blaze’s origin. 

He shared that no witnesses placed her near the fire’s starting point, nor did any forensic evidence point to her involvement.

He said the court only has claims by some witnesses that the accused had threatened to burn the dorm down and that she had collected a lighter and perfume from two students.

Todd further pointed out that on the day of the incident, some testimonies noted that other dormitory students were smoking marijuana.

Should the charges against the teenager remain, Todd warned of possible civil and constitutional actions against both the DPP’s office and the state, given the perceived lack of evidence.

The 15-year-old, currently at the Juvenile Holding Centre, was not required to enter a plea. 

The court completed full disclosure on the case on July 20.

The latest news from Guyana & The Caribbean

Read more articles about Guyana from Caribbean National Weekly

More Stories

Yashika Graham )

Jamaican Poet Yashika Graham shortlisted for 2025 OCM Bocas Prize for Poetry

Acclaimed Jamaican poet Yashika Graham has earned a coveted spot on the shortlist for the 2025 OCM Bocas Prize for Poetry with her debut...
Antigua Barbuda aerial

Antigua and Barbuda’s economy surpasses pre-pandemic levels, driven by tourism

Antigua and Barbuda’s economy continues its post-pandemic rebound, with real output surpassing pre-pandemic levels in 2024. Growth was estimated at 4.3%, fueled by a strong...
Guyana to begin Construction on seven new hospitals

Guyana aims to become regional pharmaceutical, vaccine manufacturing hub

The future of Guyana’s healthcare system is taking shape with ambitious plans to build six new hospitals, modernize outdated regulations, and establish the country...
Doctors Without Borders suspends operations again in Haiti

Doctors Without Borders suspends operations again in Haiti

Doctors Without Borders/Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) has once again suspended operations at its Turgeau Emergency Centre in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, following an alarming escalation of...
Grenada’s Opposition leader Dr Keith Mitchell says he will not be seeking re-election

Former Grenada Prime Minister Keith Mitchell collapses during political meeting

Former Grenadian Prime Minister Dr. Keith Mitchell collapsed on Monday evening while addressing supporters of the New National Party (NNP) at a political meeting...
Suriname Joins World Bank's International Development Association as Newest Member

Local World Bank employees in Jamaica now exempt from income tax

In a move that reinforces Jamaica’s relationship with the World Bank, the Senate passed legislation on March 14 exempting locally recruited World Bank employees...
Vishnu Dhanpaul Trinidad cabinet

New Trinidad PM Stuart Young announces new cabinet appointments

Newly-appointed Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago Stuart Young has unveiled his Cabinet, introducing several new appointments while retaining many key ministers. The official announcement...
Bahamas Health Minister

Bahamas Health Minister defends Cuban health workers amid US criticism

Health Minister Dr. Michael Darville has defended the presence of Cuban health workers in The Bahamas, emphasizing their crucial role in the country’s optometry...
Trinidad Prime Minister Dr. Keith Rowley

Dr. Keith Rowley calls for Trinidad to leave Privy Council in final address as PM

Former Prime Minister Dr. Keith Rowley used his final address in office to make a passionate case for Trinidad and Tobago’s exit from the...
Stuart Young

Stuart Young sworn in as Trinidad and Tobago’s 8th Prime Minister

In a historic ceremony at the President's House this morning, Stuart Young was sworn in as the 8th Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago,...

Latest Articles

Skip to content